Personal Guarantees for Business Loans: Are They Always Required?

Two colleagues smiling and talking across desks in the Lily Head Finance office.

When lending to a limited company, particularly in the SME market, lenders will often seek a personal guarantee from the directors and shareholders.

That does not necessarily mean, however, that the position is entirely non-negotiable.

Whether a personal guarantee is required, and at what level, will usually depend on factors such as the amount being borrowed, the purpose of the finance, the financial strength of the business and its trading track record.

The rationale is straightforward. A personal guarantee gives those with a beneficial interest in the business an additional incentive to do everything reasonably possible to ensure the success of the enterprise and, in turn, protect the lender’s position.

It can be helpful to think of bank lending as an investment. Strictly speaking, the bank is not simply lending “its own money”. Much of the funding available to lend comes from deposits placed with the bank by individuals and businesses, who expect both a return and, importantly, the safe return of their capital when required.

For that reason, lenders need to manage risk carefully.

The bank’s primary security will usually be the assets of the borrowing company. Depending on the size and nature of the business, this may include a fixed and floating charge, often referred to as a debenture, over the company’s assets, together with specific security over any freehold or leasehold property.

A personal guarantee is, in effect, the lender’s Plan B.

If the business fails and the realisation of its assets is insufficient to repay the borrowing in full, the guarantors may become personally liable for the remaining debt, subject to the terms and limits of the guarantee.

So, while the opening statement is often broadly correct, there can sometimes be scope for negotiation.

1. The amount of the guarantee

Some lenders will initially seek a personal guarantee covering the full amount of the company’s borrowing.

That does not always mean the final guarantee has to remain at that level.

The amount should be proportionate to the perceived risk and considered in the context of the guarantors’ personal financial position. If a proposed guarantee is materially greater than the guarantors’ net personal assets, there may be scope to negotiate the liability down to a more realistic level.

2. A future reduction or release

It may also be possible to agree circumstances in which the guarantee can be reduced or released at a later date.

For example, this could be linked to:

  • the company’s financial position strengthening to an agreed level;
  • the outstanding debt reducing below a specified amount;
  • additional equity being invested;
  • an important contract being secured; or
  • another event that materially reduces the lender’s risk.

Where possible, these milestones are best discussed and documented at the outset rather than left for a future conversation.

3. Creating competition between lenders

Competition can also play an important part.

Not all lenders assess risk in the same way. A bank with extensive experience of a particular business sector may take a more favourable view than one with less exposure or appetite in that market.

For stronger borrowers, that difference in risk appetite can sometimes result in a lower personal guarantee requirement and, in some cases, no personal guarantee at all.

The important point is that a personal guarantee should not automatically be treated as a standard term that cannot be discussed.

The lender’s starting position may be clear, but depending on the strength of the business, the structure of the transaction and the level of competition available, there may well be room to negotiate a better outcome.

If you are preparing a business loan application or looking to renegotiate existing security terms, contact the Lily Head Finance Team for expert advice.  

Or, if you want further financial advice, have a look at our previous blogs.

Facebook
LinkedIn